NJ State Worker Healthcare Updates


The Open Enrollment period for State Health Benefits Plan (SHBP) begins on October 1, 2016 and ends on October 31, 2016. Open enrollment dates may be extended. During Open Enrollment active employees in the SHBP can make changes to their dependents or enroll in a different health plan. All changes made during Open Enrollment will take effect on January 1, 2017 for state and local SHBP members.


The tiered network plans, Aetna’s Liberty Plan and Horizon’s Omnia, are voluntary and no workers will be required to select one of these plans, they are just additional options offered through the SHBP. CWA voted in favor of the creation of the Tiered Networks because we think this is an option that will fit the needs of many, but not all of our members.

State employees who switch to one of the tiered network plans during Open Enrollment as new subscribers beginning January 1, 2017 for a minimum of two years will receive incentive payments of $2000 for those with family coverage, $1250 for parent/child or employee/spouse coverage, and $1000 for single coverage. The payments will come during the first quarter of next year.

Tiered network plans are for not for everyone. However, if you will use Tier 1 doctors and hospitals, then this plan may save you money at considerably reduced premium share.  You will save 25% over the cost of Direct 15 and you will get the incentive.  Here is an example: let’s say that you are paying $400 a month toward your Direct 15 Family coverage + $150 a month for prescription.  If you took the Tiered Network, you would pay $300 a month + you would get a $2000 incentive gift card for signing up.  You would save $1200 in premiums a year and you would get $2000.   Over the course of the 2 year commitment, you would save $2400 in premium, and $2000 in incentive— $4,400.

If your doctor(s) are not Tier 1 doctors, however, the Tiered Network may not be for you.  You can check and see if your doctor(s) are in the Aetna or Horizon plans by looking at their website.  Make sure that you also check the Hospitals listed.  Only Aetna has Pennsylvania and New York Hospitals in their top tier.  

Please research your doctors/hospitals carefully. The Tiered Network has the potential to save your family a great deal of money— if it is right for you.  But it can also cost you money if it isn’t.


Any active employee member in any PPO or tiered network plan can join the Direct Primary Care pilot. You can join any time during the year— not just during open enrollment. This program does not change the plan you are in, it provides specialized primary care at no cost.

Direct Primary Care features primary care doctors who will have significantly fewer patients than now (average today of 2500 to 3000 patients per doctor versus no more than a thousand for Direct Primary Care), same day/next day appointments, 24/7 access to your doctor, and appointments that are as long as they need to be. In many ways this pilot gets back to the day when physicians could spend time with patients.

When you or a family member visits a Direct Primary Care office you will never pay a copay.

In 2016-2017 two providers will be opening offices— R Health in South Jersey and Mercer County and Paladina in North Jersey and Mercer County.   R Health will have Direct Primary Care offices open this Fall and Paladina expects to have offices open by March 2017.   We anticipate that more providers to join the Direct Primary Care program later.

This is an “add on” to all of the Direct and Tiered Network plans.  You can be in Direct 15 and join this add on or you can be in the Tiered Network.  It will not affect your premiums.   Before you decide to join one of these Direct Primary care offices, you can go to an Open House at the Doctor’s practice or go to what will be one of the many opportunities to learn about this Pilot Project.


While there no changes to copays, deductibles or covered treatment, there are several changes in Plan Design that will affect what is covered and potentially your out-of-pocket costs. There are important changes concerning prescription drugs, physical therapy. These changes were passed at the Plan Design Committee by the 6 management members and 1 union member from the Patrolman’s Benevolent Association (PBA). CWA and the rest of the Union members on the Plan Design Committee did not vote for them. However, with the PBA vote, management had a majority vote and succeeded in putting these changes through

1.     Prescription Drugs

There are three changes to prescription drug coverage.  In all cases, if you need a drug that is not covered under the changes, there is an appeals process and during the appeals process you will continue to get the drug that you were prescribed. In all cases, the union members of the Plan Design Committee are closely monitoring these changes. For the mandatory generic and formulary programs, next year the Plan Design Committee will have to affirmatively vote to continue the changes.

• Mandatory Generics

Effective December 1, if there is no medical reason for using a brand drug, when a generic equivalent of that drug is available, only the generic drug will be covered.

Currently, if a state worker insists upon taking a brand medication when there is a generic, and you do not have a medical reason for doing so— you can get the brand if you pay a higher copay for it.

If you do have a medical reason for taking a brand, (you get a rash from the generic, it gives you headaches, etc.,) you will be able to produce that medical evidence and you should be able to get the brand. BUT if you can’t produce that medical evidence, the brand medicine (when a generic is available) will not be covered.

CWA does not expect this to be a problem for 99% of our members, but if you have any problem with it please let your Local know. This program will expire after one year unless the Plan Design Committee extends it.

• Step Therapy

Step therapy will now apply to all State employees, where members will be required to try a more cost-effective drug before trying a more expensive drug.

Background: In 2009, the SHBP unilaterally put in a step therapy program— meaning they wanted some people to try one drug and see if it worked before trying a more expensive drug. CWA challenged this under the state worker contract and won a big arbitration case which prevented most state workers from being covered by step therapy. Step Therapy was put in place for Local Government, Rutgers and for state management.

We do not expect this to have a significant impact on our members, but again, if you have a problem with it, if you need a different drug and submit an appeal, please let your Local know.

• Prescription Formulary

Effective December 1, nearly all prescription drug plans including the SHBP retiree RX plan, now have a prescription “formulary” of preferred and non-preferred drugs. Much of the time this is just about negotiating a better price for test strips or particular catheter tubes.  Other times it is about specific drugs themselves being excluded. We have never had a formulary. Your doctor wrote a prescription, you got that drug. Under the new plan for active members, some supplies and drugs will not be available except if is medically necessary that you take that drug rather than the drug on the formulary.

We do not expect many problems from the formulary, however, we do have members whose doctors do not want them on the formulary drugs for medical reasons and they will need to appeal. We will be closely monitoring this program— it will expire after one year unless the Plan Design Committee votes to extend it.

2.     Physical Therapy

Effective November 1, reimbursement to out-of-network physical therapists will change. The Out-of-network physical therapists will no longer receive higher reimbursement than in-network therapists. We do not anticipate a negative impact on members.  We will be working with the Physical Therapists’ Association to encourage the use of physical therapy to speed recovery and lessen the use of more painful and difficult pain relief options.


Effective January 1, 2017, AON recommended overall increases of 3.4% for active employees to the total premium costs of the medical and prescription drug plans. The overall increase reflects the impact of a:

·         1.9% increase in Single and Employee+Spouse rates,

·         a 4.4% increase in the Family rates, and

·         a 5.9% increase in Employee+Child(ren) rates.

The recommended renewal increases were calculated separately for the PPO (which includes the High Deductible plans), HMO, and Prescription Drug Plans.


Rates for the Dental Expense Plan are going up 2.8% for actives and 5.1% for retirees. Rates for the five Dental Plan Organizations: a 5% decrease for MetLife and Horizon, premiums are unchanged for Healthplex and Aetna and a 2% increase for Cigna. Dental Provider Organizations feature very narrow networks.